Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Tanya Bennett

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent

Tanya Bennett

536 North 8th Street
Middletown, IN 47356-1027

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Tanya Bennett

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

Mon-Fri 9:00am to 4:45 pm

Saturday & Evenings by Appt.


536 North 8th Street
Middletown, IN 47356-1027



Spring and summer are on the way!!

We would be honored to quote your insurance, please call, text or pay us a visit. My team and I are ready to help with all your insurance and financial service needs.

I have over 40 years of insurance experience, and I have learned the value of providing outstanding customer service to everyone, all the time. I’m proud to serve the residents of Middletown, IN and the surrounding areas—including Daleville, Chesterfield, Pendleton, Yorktown, Anderson, New Castle, & Muncie. My licensed and dedicated team welcomes you, and we handle everything from home, renters insurance, car insurance, boat, RV, motorcycles, and life insurance.

I have a passion for taking care of people, helping them take care of themselves, and being a State Farm agent gives me a chance to do that every day. I love meeting people and hearing their stories, everyone is unique, and they deserve an agent who knows that and who will give them personalized service and individual attention. My team and I serve a critical need in the community by helping people plan for the future and recover from the unexpected.

I have been in the area since 1994. I have a husband, daughter, son-in-law, and two grandchildren. We enjoy spending time together as a family. I enjoy reading, boating, attending BSF, being an AWANA leader, and most of all playing with my grandchildren.

My agency and I have a reputation for honesty, empathy, and a deep understanding of insurance. We love pitching in and helping out however we can in the community and surrounding areas. As a business owner in Middletown, I consider it both my responsibility and an honor to help support my friends and neighbors when unexpected events occur.

My team and I are always willing to spend extra time to explain your coverage and make sure you’re comfortable. And we’re always ready to help YOU find the right insurance for your needs.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health

Should I finance a car or pay cash for it?

Should you finance a car or pay cash? This calculator can help you decide what option is best when you are ready to buy your next car, truck or suv.

Share the road with farm vehicles

Rural road driving might feel safe & relaxing but they are shared with farm vehicles & have risks. Here are tips to help when driving in the country.

How to plan for college visits

Planning for college visits can be exciting and stressful. We review how to narrow down the best places to visit and how to plan for these college tours.

View More Articles

Our mission is to help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected, and realize their dreams.

Letha Caldwell is my office manager. She has worked for me since 2007, so has over 16 years of experience. Letha is a consumate professional. She is always ready and willing to help you with any insurance needs, and goes above and beyond to make sure you are taken care of in a timely manner. I'm grateful to have her working alongside me in the office.
Letha Caldwell State Farm Agent Team Member

Letha Caldwell

Office Manager

I have worked for Tanya since 2007. I enjoy creating personal relationships with insureds, helping them with their insurance needs, and working in our community. My personal interests include gardening, camping, spending time with my family, and crafting.